We often dogsit for friends and family, and having a second dog in the house is such a joy. The sight of them playing, sharing toys, and cuddling together is not just heartwarming but also incredibly entertaining. But is getting a second dog full-time practical—or even feasible?
Owning two dogs brings double the love but also double the responsibility. Will the extra time, cost, and effort fit into your lifestyle? Will your current dog benefit from a companion or feel stressed by the change? Let’s break down the pros and cons to help you decide.
Affiliate Disclosure: We participate in several affiliate programs. The commissions from eligible purchases are at no cost to you and allow us to continue producing valuable content. We appreciate your support! For full disclosure, read here.
Pros of Getting a Second Dog
Built-In Buddy
Adding a second dog gives your current dog a constant companion. Dogs are social animals, and having a buddy can help reduce boredom, ease loneliness, and even alleviate separation anxiety. This reassurance that your first dog will benefit from the new addition can give you the confidence to consider a second dog.
It’s been incredible for us to see how much calmer our dog, Nala, is when she has company. When we leave her alone, she’s often anxious and wound up by the time we return. But when another dog is around, she’s relaxed and content, showing how much she benefits from a playmate.
Positive Impacts on Both Dogs
A younger dog can bring new energy to your home and inspire your older dog to stay active and engaged. When my sister watches our dog, her elderly Labrador, who usually sleeps much of the day, becomes noticeably livelier. She wags her tail more, joins in on playtime, and shows a side of herself we rarely see.
A second dog also reintroduces structured training, which often fades as dogs age. Puppies naturally mimic older dogs, making training easier for both. Meanwhile, the older dog gets a refresher, reinforcing good habits while bonding with their new companion. Together, they create a more balanced and well-behaved pack dynamic.
Easing the Loss of an Older Dog
When my mother-in-law’s 16-year-old Doberman passed away, her second dog softened the pain of the loss. While no dog can replace another, the presence of a second dog can ease the heartache. The house doesn’t feel as empty, and there’s still a pet to love and care for, helping her heal after such a difficult goodbye.
Cons of Getting a Second Dog
Increased Financial Commitment
A second dog means double the expenses. Food, grooming, vet visits, and supplies like toys and bedding can quickly add up. If you travel, boarding or pet-sitting costs will also increase. Before bringing home another dog, ensure you’re ready for the financial responsibility.
Reduced Flexibility
Traveling, social outings, and spontaneous plans become more challenging with two dogs. Pet-friendly accommodations often charge more for additional pets, and finding someone to watch two dogs can be difficult. If you enjoy traveling or have a busy schedule, a second dog requires more planning and adjustments.
Potential Compatibility Issues
Not all dogs get along naturally, and adding a new dog can lead to challenges. Your current dog’s personality, as well as the age and temperament of the new dog, will determine how well they adapt. It’s necessary to allow time for proper introductions and a transition period to ensure harmony between the two.
Adding a second dog can bring companionship, energy, and joy to your home, but it also comes with challenges. Consider the financial, logistical, and emotional aspects carefully before making a decision. With the right preparation, a second dog could enhance your family life and bring even more love into your home.
